Have you ever felt depressed and anxious? Of course you have – that’s like asking you if you’ve ever had the common cold.
All of us get depressed and anxious at least occasionally. Sometimes we may go through particularly difficult seasons of chronic depression or anxiety, or have episodes that come and go.
But what causes depression and anxiety? Unless you’ve lived in a cave over the past 20-30 years you must have heard the explanation that depression and anxiety are due to a “chemical imbalance” in the brain.
According to this theory, disordered brain chemistry makes us feel moody, blue, tense, worried, etc. In turn, faulty genes are thought to make us vulnerable to these imbalances.
In response to this condition, the pharmaceutical companies have been hard at work – and spending billions of dollars – developing medications to help us with these conditions, especially over the last 25 years.
Just as insulin is designed to help diabetics keep their blood sugar under control – according to this perspective – these medications are supposed to help those who are prone to depression and anxiety keep their brain chemistry in balance – and therefore relieve them of their symptoms.
At first glance, this may seem like an elegant solution. Chemical imbalances cause us to feel depressed and anxious, and drug companies have created “better living through chemistry” – to quote an old advertising slogan – by creating cutting edge medications to restore the balance.
Sounds like a marriage made in heaven – right?
It would seem that way, since the drug companies have done such an effective job of promoting this theory through billions of dollars in advertising over the years. As a result, many have just come to accept this theory as if it were fact.
After all, if there is a chemical cause of depression and anxiety, it makes sense to conclude that the cure must also be chemical.
But does the chemical imbalance theory – which in turn leads to the theory of the chemical cure – hold any water?
The answer is no – for a number of reasons that include the following:
The chemical imbalance theory is unproven. There are no studies that support the notion that chemical imbalances in the human brain cause depression and anxiety. There is not even way to test for a chemical imbalance in the brain. But don’t take my word for it – click here: Is there a test for a chemical imbalance?
The medications are not effective. Even if there was a chemical imbalance in the brain underlying depression and anxiety, the medications are not nearly as effective as we have been led to believe, if they are even effective at all. For this reason, some researchers have suggested that success of these medications is due more to effective marketing than sound science.
The placebo effect. If you or a loved one have been on a medication for depression and anxiety and started to feel better, you might protest the notion that these medications do not work. But 30 – 50% of people will feel significantly better if you merely give them a sugar pill and tell them that it is a medication for depression and anxiety. This is known as the placebo effect.
As such, if a drug company tells you that their new medication helps 75% of the people who take it, the placebo effect needs to be subtracted from that – which would suggest that such a medication is effective only 25% – 45% of the time. That doesn’t sound so good, however, in an advertisement for a new drug that cost billions of dollars to develop.
Side effects exceed the benefits. “But at least these medications help some people,” you might say. Consider, however, the costs versus the benefits. There are literal costs associated with medications which are typically quite expensive, but aside from that there are numerous side effects – both short-term and long-term – that override what little benefit, if any, come from taking medications for depression and anxiety.
In addition, anxiety medications in particular often have a potential for addiction, so much so that drug abuse treatment for anxiety medication has tripled over the last 10 years.
Keep the above in mind the next time you hear the conventional wisdom that depression and anxiety are due to a chemical imbalance.
Unfortunately, all of us will experience episodes of depression and anxiety from time to time in life, but the good news is that there are many things that can be done to turn around a bad mood without medications, as I will explain in my next post.
What do you think about the chemical imbalance theory? What makes you feel better when you feel depressed and anxious?
Learn more about Depression and Anxiety therapy and how these services can help you.
Related articles




