Depression is one of the most common mental health problems. Symptoms of depression include sadness, hopelessness, and feeling of worthlessness. Is this how you’re feeling right now? If so, you’re probably looking for anything to give you relief from your symptoms.
One of the most common treatments for this condition is antidepressant medication. Perhaps you’re taking one now, or considering it. Do want to know more about the safety and effectiveness of these medications?
If so, that would be wise. For there are many reasons to question the usefulness of antidepressants given what we now know. There are also effective ways for treating depression without antidepressants.
How Common Is Depression?
The National Institute of Mental Health estimates that 8.2% of adults suffer from depression. This makes depression one of the most common mental disorders in the United States.
Among this group, 1.5% suffer from Dysthymic Disorder. This condition consists of chronic, low-grade depression..
The other part of this group is the 6.7% of adults who suffer from Major Depression. This is a more serious form of depression. For some, it can be debilitating.
To a lesser degree, just about everyone gets depressed at some point. It is a common reaction to a loss, disappointment, failure, or setback. For most people, these episodes are mild and brief.
For others – such as those above – it leads to clinical depression..
How Often Are Antidepressants Prescribed?
While antidepressants have been around for decades, they have have been prescribed more frequently in recent years.
In particular, a subtype known as SSRIs (selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors) has become the most popular type of antidepressant over the past 25 years.
Antidepressant use among adults has skyrocketed during this time. Recent estimates suggest 1 in 10 Americans age 12 and older take now antidepressant medication. These same estimates indicate that antidepressant use has increased 400% from 1988 to 2008.
As a result of this explosion, the prospect of treating depression without antidepressants is often not even considered. Surely these medications are the most effective treatment for depression. Or are they?
The results are not conclusive.
One reason for this is that most people who are prescribed these medications do not even receive a proper evaluation. That’s because most antidepressants are usually prescribed by general practitioners and other non-psychiatrist physicians.
As a result, estimates indicate that almost 73% of antidepressants are prescribed to patients without a formal psychiatric diagnosis.
In other words, in most cases people are being prescribed antidepressants before it has even been determined that they have depression.
The Myth of the Chemical Imbalance
The rise in antidepressant prescriptions in recent decades is closely related to the biological model of depression.
This theory suggests that certain brain chemicals are out of balance in depression. In particular, such theories often argue that a lack of a brain chemical known as Serotonin is a key cause of depression.
As such, antidepressants are supposed to correct the chemical imbalance thought to cause depression.
Once the balance is restored, then depression should be cured. At least that is what is supposed to happen on paper.
For over two decades, drug company advertising has led us to believe that this is the case – which is why you need to take their pills. Surely then, this theory must have been conclusively proven, yes?
Not really.
It has been difficult to prove the chemical imbalance theory of depression. As scientific as it may sound, there is surprisingly little evidence to support it.
In fact, did you know there is no test to detect a chemical imbalance in the brain? And even if there was, there is no consensus on what “balanced” brain chemistry looks like.
Are the Side Effects of Antidepressants Worth the Risk?
Antidepressants also carry with them the potential for numerous side effects.
These include, but are not limited to, the following:
- Nausea
- Nervousness, agitation or restlessness
- Dizziness
- Reduced sexual desire
- Insomnia
- Weight gain or loss
In addition to those mentioned above, the potential for violent side effects from taking antidepressants is even more worrisome. This includes increased risk for suicide and homicide.
The concerns about suicide are found to be especially high when antidepressants are taken by children and young adults. This led the FDA to issue a black box warning in 2004 indicating that antidepressants were associated with an increased risk of suicidal thinking, feeling, and behavior in young people.
How Effective are Antidepressants?
If antidepressants were found to be effective, you might argue that the benefits outweigh the risks. Depression can be agonizing – especially when it is severe – and it is natural to grasp for anything that might provide relief.
In this way, if depression were like cancer, then antidepressants might be like chemotherapy. The side effects might be harsh, but they would be the lesser of two evils compared to the disease.
But this does not appear to be the case. More than one study has found that antidepressant medication has little if any effectiveness above and beyond the placebo effect.
In other words, when patients are given a sugar pill and led to believe that it is an antidepressant, their improvement is close to or equivalent to those taking the actual medication. They believe the medication to be effective, therefore they improve.
As such, estimates suggest that as much as 80% of the effectiveness of antidepressant medications is due to the placebo effect. In turn, drug companies have hidden these poor results by selectively publishing clinical trials to make antidepressants seem more effective than they really are.
As such, not only is the chemical imbalance theory of depression not proven, but so is the notion that you have to take a pill to correct this so-called imbalance.
How to Beat Depression Without Pills
Did you know that there are ways to overcome depression without medications?
Treating depression without antidepressants is entirely realistic. Non-medication treatments for depression are not only more effective, but also don’t have the risks associated with antidepressants. And given the weak data on the effectiveness of medications, they may be your only ready alternative.
There is great hope to be able to overcome and control depression without the use of medication, and to do so more effectively.
Exercise
As mentioned above, there is surprisingly little evidence to support the chemical imbalance theory of depression.
Even if there was a chemical imbalance associated with depression, however, it does not follow that one has to take a pill to correct this imbalance.
Exercise is increasingly being found to be an effective treatment for depression. While the reasons for this are still being studied, an increase in the production of endorphins and a decrease in stress hormones appear to be at least a couple of the benefits of exercise in fighting depression.
In addition, exercise is just one of several lifestyle changes that can help one overcome depression by living a healthier life.
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
Exercise may not be enough for some people who are depressed. Although it can have a tremendous benefit to our physical health, exercise does not by itself address the negative thoughts that are also associated with depression.
As such, cognitive-behavioral therapy is an effective form of therapy for depression. It can be used in addition to – or instead of – exercise to treat depression.
This form of therapy is designed to address the negative thoughts associated with depression. These thoughts tend to be very pessimistic, gloomy, and hopeless. When you’re depressed, these thoughts also seem highly believable, and therefore you feel and behave accordingly.
Cognitive-behavioral therapy emphasizes teaching skills for overcoming depression, rather than prescribing pills. Once you learn these skills, you will have them the rest of your life and they will only get better with practice.
In time, you will will be able to develop the confidence that you can overcome depression and future relapses if you learn the skills.
Conclusion
The bad news about depression is that it can make you miserable.
The good news about it is that it is a very treatable condition if you get effective help.
Unfortunately, you have probably been lead to believe over the years that you have a chemical imbalance in your brain. In turn, you may have been led to believe that your only hope for relief is through antidepressants.
There are alternatives that exist for treating depression without antidepressants. Not only is this possible, but it is advisable given the questionable effectiveness of these medications. In addition, there are also numerous side effects to consider.
If you’d like to explore how to beat depression without drugs, feel free to explore my perspectives on depression, and contact me if you’d like help learning how to overcome depression through skills, not pills.
